Ex-DraftKings executive loses appeal of Fanatics work restrictions
By Nate Raymond
BOSTON, Sept 26 (Reuters) -A federal appeals court on Thursday rejected a former DraftKings DKNG.O executive's bid to overturn an injunction that severely restricts the type of work he can do now that he has joined its sports betting rival Fanatics.
The Boston-based 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Michael Hermalyn's bid to have California law applied to the dispute over his non-compete agreement with DraftKings, which would have rendered it unenforceable, and instead held Massachusetts law governed.
"Massachusetts and California aren't exactly on the same page when it comes to non-compete agreements," Senior U.S. Circuit Judge O. Rogeriee Thompson acknowledged in her opinion for the three-judge panel.
She noted that Massachusetts, where DraftKings is based, generally allows non-competes for higher-level employees like Hermalyn, while California, where he now lives, largely bans such agreements unless they fit within a few narrow exceptions.
Given that backdrop and the facts of the case, "we can't say that Hermalyn has shown (as he was required to do) that California's 'interest' in pursuing its policy is not just 'greater' than Massachusetts's, but is 'materially' so," Thompson wrote.
Lawyers for Hermalyn did not immediately respond to requests for comment, nor did DraftKings. A spokesperson for Fanatics declined to comment.
DraftKings sued Hermalyn, its senior vice president of growth, after he moved to California and resigned on Feb. 1 ahead of the Super Bowl to join Fanatics, a company best known for selling sports jerseys and merchandise that last year launched its own sportsbook.
DraftKings sought to block Hermalyn, who oversaw its relationships with its largest VIP customers, from working for Fanatics, which had hired him to help build out its own nascent team catering to VIP clients.
DraftKings accused him of violating his non-compete and non-solicitation agreements and alleged he misappropriated trade secrets before joining Fanatics and tried to poach some of its employees.
It secured a preliminary injunction in April from U.S. District Judge Julia Kobick in Boston that severely restricted the work he could do at Fanatics but that stopped short of barring him from working at the company.
She cited evidence that Hermalyn in the days before resigning from DraftKings used unauthorized means to transfer DraftKings documents to himself and accessed some while staying at the Los Angeles home of Fanatics CEO Michael Rubin.
The judge enjoined him for a 12-month time period starting when he began his new job on Feb. 1 from providing services relating to any aspects of DraftKings' business that he was involved in or for which he had received confidential information.
Hermalyn denies stealing trade secrets and filed a separate lawsuit challenging the non-compete agreement in California.
He has argued that California law should apply because not only does he live there now but also because that's where the Fanatics subsidiary he heads is based, giving the state a greater interest in the matter.
A week before the 1st Circuit heard arguments in the case, a California state court judge concluded that Hermalyn was likely to prevail on the merits of his case under California law. But the judge declined to issue a preliminary injunction, citing the Massachusetts lawsuit.
The case is DraftKings Inc v. Hermalyn, 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-1443.
For DraftKings: Thomas Dupree of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher
For Hermalyn: Christopher Michel of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Read more:
Ex-DraftKings executive appeals restrictions on work at Fanatics
Ex-DraftKings exec denies accessing trade secrets before Fanatics job jump
DraftKings trade-secret case is 'character assassination,' Fanatics exec says
Ex-DraftKings exec can work at Fanatics, can't solicit clients during Super Bowl: judge
DraftKings sues former executive for taking secrets to sports-betting rival
Reporting by Nate Raymond in Boston
Últimas notícias
Isenção de Responsabilidade: As entidades do XM Group proporcionam serviço de apenas-execução e acesso à nossa plataforma online de negociação, permitindo a visualização e/ou uso do conteúdo disponível no website ou através deste, o que não se destina a alterar ou a expandir o supracitado. Tal acesso e uso estão sempre sujeitos a: (i) Termos e Condições; (ii) Avisos de Risco; e (iii) Termos de Responsabilidade. Este, é desta forma, fornecido como informação generalizada. Particularmente, por favor esteja ciente que os conteúdos da nossa plataforma online de negociação não constituem solicitação ou oferta para iniciar qualquer transação nos mercados financeiros. Negociar em qualquer mercado financeiro envolve um nível de risco significativo de perda do capital.
Todo o material publicado na nossa plataforma de negociação online tem apenas objetivos educacionais/informativos e não contém — e não deve ser considerado conter — conselhos e recomendações financeiras, de negociação ou fiscalidade de investimentos, registo de preços de negociação, oferta e solicitação de transação em qualquer instrumento financeiro ou promoção financeira não solicitada direcionadas a si.
Qual conteúdo obtido por uma terceira parte, assim como o conteúdo preparado pela XM, tais como, opiniões, pesquisa, análises, preços, outra informação ou links para websites de terceiras partes contidos neste website são prestados "no estado em que se encontram", como um comentário de mercado generalizado e não constitui conselho de investimento. Na medida em que qualquer conteúdo é construído como pesquisa de investimento, deve considerar e aceitar que este não tem como objetivo e nem foi preparado de acordo com os requisitos legais concebidos para promover a independência da pesquisa de investimento, desta forma, deve ser considerado material de marketing sob as leis e regulações relevantes. Por favor, certifique-se que leu e compreendeu a nossa Notificação sobre Pesquisa de Investimento não-independente e o Aviso de Risco, relativos à informação supracitada, os quais podem ser acedidos aqui.
