U.S. Treasuries not the safe bet they once were, research says
Adds comments from U.S. officials
By Ann Saphir and Howard Schneider
JACKSON HOLE, Wyoming, Aug 23 (Reuters) -No safer than a bund. Or a gilt. Or an OAT.
Long touted as hands-down the world's "safe haven" securities, the behavior of U.S. Treasuries during and after the COVID-19 pandemic calls that label into question, suggesting they are little different from the debt issued by the likes of Germany, Britain, France, or even big corporations.
That's the key finding of new research presented at the Kansas City Fed's annual research conference in Jackson Hole, Wyoming. It examines a shift in investor behavior in that period that raises questions about the "exorbitant privilege" the U.S. government has long enjoyed to borrow broadly on the global market even as federal budget gaps grow ever wider.
It's a timely question given growing deficits are seen as a near certainty regardless of who becomes the next U.S. president.
New York University's Roberto Gomez-Cram, London Business School's Howard Kung and Stanford University's Hanno Lustig also throw into question the assertion that the Treasury market was dysfunctional in that period - as asserted by the Federal Reserve when it launched its massive bond buying - or just rationally pricing the risk of a massive unfunded spending shock then being prepared in response to the health emergency.
"In response to COVID, U.S. Treasury investors seem to have shifted to the risky debt model when pricing Treasurys," wrote New York University's Roberto Gomez-Cram, London Business School's Howard Kung and Stanford University's Hanno Lustig in the paper. "Policymakers, including central banks, should internalize this shift when assessing whether bond markets are functioning properly."
The researchers looked at the behavior of Treasuries securities during the pandemic shutdown of 2020, when yields shot higher not just for U.S. debt but for bonds issued by nations across the globe.
They found that investors did not, as they had during previous episodes of global financial stress, pile into Treasuries and drive up their value. Instead, investors marked down Treasury securities, much as they did for bonds from other countries.
Meanwhile the U.S. Federal Reserve responded to the spike in U.S. Treasury yields as if it were a result of market dislocation, they said, buying up bonds to bring back order to the world's usually most liquid debt market as they had during the Global Financial Crisis.
"In the risky debt regime, valuations will respond to government spending shocks, which may involve large yield changes in bond markets," the researchers said, noting that they found especially big market moves on days when fiscal stimulus was announced.
"In this environment, large-scale asset purchases by central banks in response to a large government spending increase have undesirable public finance implications," they wrote. "These purchases, which provide temporary price support, destroy value for taxpayers but subsidize bondholders" and may also encourage governments to overestimate their true fiscal capacity, they wrote.
PUSHBACK
The paper drew pushback from the audience, including Treasury Department officials and others who said it needed to account for uncertainty unleashed around the pandemic, the fact that hundreds of billions of dollars of fiscal response to the crisis was financed without trouble, and that more recently U.S. bond yields had been dropping even with continued large deficit spending.
The paper did not reflect "the uncertainty in the episode," U.S. Treasury Under Secretary for Domestic Finance Nellie Liang said in comments from the floor of the conference.
She noted that "with the passage of the Cares Act there is more than a trillion dollars of debt….and there is no sign of problems in that even during March or April" when global governments were first reacting to the health crisis.
Reporting by Ann Saphir and Howard Schneider and Dan Burns; Editing by Chizu Nomiyama
Ultime news
Disclaimer: le entità di XM Group forniscono servizi di sola esecuzione e accesso al nostro servizio di trading online, che permette all'individuo di visualizzare e/o utilizzare i contenuti disponibili sul sito o attraverso di esso; non ha il proposito di modificare o espandere le proprie funzioni, né le modifica o espande. L'accesso e l'utilizzo sono sempre soggetti a: (i) Termini e condizioni; (ii) Avvertenza sui rischi e (iii) Disclaimer completo. Tali contenuti sono perciò forniti a scopo puramente informativo. Nello specifico, ti preghiamo di considerare che i contenuti del nostro servizio di trading online non rappresentano un sollecito né un'offerta ad operare sui mercati finanziari. Il trading su qualsiasi mercato finanziario comporta un notevole livello di rischio per il tuo capitale.
Tutto il materiale pubblicato sul nostro servizio di trading online è unicamente a scopo educativo e informativo, e non contiene (e non dovrebbe essere considerato come contenente) consigli e raccomandazioni di carattere finanziario, di trading o fiscale, né informazioni riguardanti i nostri prezzi di trading, offerte o solleciti riguardanti transazioni che possano coinvolgere strumenti finanziari, oppure promozioni finanziarie da te non richieste.
Tutti i contenuti di terze parti, oltre ai contenuti offerti da XM, siano essi opinioni, news, ricerca, analisi, prezzi, altre informazioni o link a siti di terzi presenti su questo sito, sono forniti "così com'è", e vanno considerati come commenti generali sui mercati; per questo motivo, non possono essere visti come consigli di investimento. Dato che tutti i contenuti sono intesi come ricerche di investimento, devi considerare e accettare che non sono stati preparati né creati seguendo i requisiti normativi pensati per promuovere l'indipendenza delle ricerche di investimento; per questo motivo, questi contenuti devono essere considerati come comunicazioni di marketing in base alle leggi e normative vigenti. Assicurati di avere letto e compreso pienamente la nostra Notifica sulla ricerca di investimento non indipendente e la nostra Informativa sul rischio riguardante le informazioni sopra citate; tali documenti sono consultabili qui.