US appeals court clears Kalshi to restart elections betting
Adds comments by nonprofit organization Better Markets, paragraphs 14-15
Court says CFTC failed to show harm from KalshiEX's event contracts
Ruling allows trading of political event contracts before U.S. elections
Critics warn contracts could undermine election integrity
By Laura Matthews
WASHINGTON, Oct 2 (Reuters) -A U.S. federal appeals court on Wednesday upheld a lower court's order that permitted New York derivatives trading platform KalshiEX LLC to list contracts that allow Americans to bet on election outcomes.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit said that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, KalshiEX's regulator, did not show how the agency or the public interest would be harmed by KalshiEX's "event" contracts, as it had argued. The CFTC declined to comment.
The ruling means that Kalshi can offer trading in such contracts, potentially paving the way for other firms to offer such derivatives in the future. The U.S. elections will be held on Nov. 5.
"Ensuring the integrity of elections and avoiding improper interference and misinformation are undoubtedly paramount public interests, and a substantiated risk of distorting the electoral process would amount to irreparable harm," the ruling read.
"The problem is that the CFTC has given this court no concrete basis to conclude that event contracts would likely be a vehicle for such harms."
Kalshi sought permission from the CFTC in June 2023 to list contracts that would let Americans bet on whether a particular party will control the House of Representatives and Senate in a given term.
But the CFTC prohibited Kalshi from listing and clearing its cash-settled political event contracts due to concerns about unlawful gaming and other activities that it said were not in the public's interest. Kalshi sued, saying the CFTC exceeded its authority.
A D.C. District Court judge sided with Kalshi in September, ruling that its contracts do not involve unlawful activity or gaming but instead involve elections, which are neither. That cleared the way for Americans to trade political event contracts ahead of next month's presidential election, which polls indicate will be one of the closest in recent history.
But the CFTC immediately appealed, requesting an emergency stay on the lower court's order.
The case tests the scope of the CFTC's regulatory authority.
CFTC Chairman Rostin Behnam has said that event contracts would effectively turn the agency into an "election cop," and that these contracts are not in the public's interest.
Critics also believe the contracts pose a threat to election integrity and could undermine democracy if elections are reduced to a gaming activity.
But proponents say the contracts could be a valuable new financial tool that provides a signal and more truth about what the future holds.
Stephen Hall, legal director and securities specialist at Better Markets, a nonprofit organization that seeks to promote the public interest in the financial markets, said the appeals court's decision marks "a sad and ominous day for election integrity" in the U.S.
"There is no way to undo the potential damage to the public interest of allowing bets in the final weeks of an election year," Hall said in a press statement.
Reporting by Michelle Price and Laura Matthews in Washington; Editing by Kevin Liffey and Matthew Lewis
Dernières actualités
Avertissement : Les entités de XM Group proposent à notre plateforme de trading en ligne un service d'exécution uniquement, autorisant une personne à consulter et/ou à utiliser le contenu disponible sur ou via le site internet, qui n'a pas pour but de modifier ou d'élargir cette situation. De tels accès et utilisation sont toujours soumis aux : (i) Conditions générales ; (ii) Avertissements sur les risques et (iii) Avertissement complet. Un tel contenu n'est par conséquent fourni que pour information générale. En particulier, sachez que les contenus de notre plateforme de trading en ligne ne sont ni une sollicitation ni une offre de participation à toute transaction sur les marchés financiers. Le trading sur les marchés financiers implique un niveau significatif de risques pour votre capital.
Tout le matériel publié dans notre Centre de trading en ligne est destiné à des fins de formation / d'information uniquement et ne contient pas – et ne doit pas être considéré comme contenant – des conseils et recommandations en matière de finance, de fiscalité des investissements ou de trading, ou un enregistrement de nos prix de trading ou une offre, une sollicitation, une transaction à propos de tout instrument financier ou bien des promotions financières non sollicitées à votre égard.
Tout contenu tiers, de même que le contenu préparé par XM, tels que les opinions, actualités, études, analyses, prix, autres informations ou liens vers des sites tiers contenus sur ce site internet sont fournis "tels quels", comme commentaires généraux sur le marché et ne constituent pas des conseils en investissement. Dans la mesure où tout contenu est considéré comme de la recherche en investissement, vous devez noter et accepter que le contenu n'a pas été conçu ni préparé conformément aux exigences légales visant à promouvoir l'indépendance de la recherche en investissement et, en tant que tel, il serait considéré comme une communication marketing selon les lois et réglementations applicables. Veuillez vous assurer que vous avez lu et compris notre Avis sur la recherche en investissement non indépendante et notre avertissement sur les risques concernant les informations susdites, qui peuvent consultés ici.
