Italy has more to gain from France’s pain
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Neil Unmack
LONDON, Oct 14 (Reuters Breakingviews) -Italy has more to gain from France’s pain. Rome’s borrowing costs are converging with those of Paris, thanks to the relative stability and fiscal assurances of Giorgia Meloni’s government. To gain a longer-term edge on her neighbours, though, Meloni will need to take bolder action.
Italian and French debt, the two behemoths of the euro zone bond market, are swapping roles. The extra premium investors demand to hold French debt over equivalent German notes is rising, as investors worry about new Prime Minister Michel Barnier’s ability to tame runaway deficits. And Rome’s so-called spreads are falling. The result: the yield gap between Italian and French debt is now just over 50 basis points, down from nearly 120 basis points at the start of the year, and at levels not seen for over a decade.
Calm politics explains part of the narrowing. Meloni’s majority government has little opposition. Barnier, by contrast, may not last if the austerity programme he has announced loses support from parties including Marine Le Pen’s National Rally. The fiscal challenge facing Meloni is arguably smaller than Barnier’s, despite Italy’s high debt and low growth. That debt burden has actually been falling as post-pandemic inflation swelled the size of salaries and tax receipts.
Italy’s debt, which had rocketed to 154% of GDP in 2020, is now 136% of national output. Cutting it further will get harder as inflation falls. Still, this year Meloni should bring in more tax than she spends, before factoring in interest payments. This so-called primary surplus would only need to rise by around 0.5% of GDP to keep debt stable as a proportion of GDP over the next four years. That’s according to Breakingviews calculations that assume average GDP growth of around 1% as per Citigroup forecasts, inflation of 2%, and current borrowing costs. For France, the fiscal squeeze needed to stabilise debt is equivalent to over 2% of GDP. That’s also assuming a higher growth rate of 1.4%.
And, despite Rome’s vast debt pile of nearly 3 trillion euros, a vibrant domestic retail investor base ought to keep yields in check. UBS estimates Italians have some 100 billion euros of excess savings, some of which may flow into bonds as the European Central Bank cuts rates, and cash returns fall.
To achieve lasting improvements, though, Meloni will need to boost the country’s sclerotic growth. That will get harder as the economic tailwind from European pandemic funds passes after 2027, and as the population rapidly ages. Her government is pushing through reforms such as cutting the lengthy time taken to process court cases. But she could be bolder in, for example, boosting education and female work participation, or privatising assets. To really catch up with France, Italy cannot sit on its laurels.
Follow @Unmack1 on X
CONTEXT NEWS
The extra premium investors demand to hold 10-year Italian debt over equivalent German debt has narrowed from over 200 basis points in October 2023 to just below 130 basis points, as of Oct. 11. The so-called spread between Italy’s sovereign bonds and French debt is now just 52 basis points, the lowest level since 2010.
Graphic: Italian debt yields are falling closer to France’s https://reut.rs/3YkAkCH
Editing by Francesco Guerrera and Oliver Taslic
Actifs liés
Dernières actualités
Avertissement : Les entités de XM Group proposent à notre plateforme de trading en ligne un service d'exécution uniquement, autorisant une personne à consulter et/ou à utiliser le contenu disponible sur ou via le site internet, qui n'a pas pour but de modifier ou d'élargir cette situation. De tels accès et utilisation sont toujours soumis aux : (i) Conditions générales ; (ii) Avertissements sur les risques et (iii) Avertissement complet. Un tel contenu n'est par conséquent fourni que pour information générale. En particulier, sachez que les contenus de notre plateforme de trading en ligne ne sont ni une sollicitation ni une offre de participation à toute transaction sur les marchés financiers. Le trading sur les marchés financiers implique un niveau significatif de risques pour votre capital.
Tout le matériel publié dans notre Centre de trading en ligne est destiné à des fins de formation / d'information uniquement et ne contient pas – et ne doit pas être considéré comme contenant – des conseils et recommandations en matière de finance, de fiscalité des investissements ou de trading, ou un enregistrement de nos prix de trading ou une offre, une sollicitation, une transaction à propos de tout instrument financier ou bien des promotions financières non sollicitées à votre égard.
Tout contenu tiers, de même que le contenu préparé par XM, tels que les opinions, actualités, études, analyses, prix, autres informations ou liens vers des sites tiers contenus sur ce site internet sont fournis "tels quels", comme commentaires généraux sur le marché et ne constituent pas des conseils en investissement. Dans la mesure où tout contenu est considéré comme de la recherche en investissement, vous devez noter et accepter que le contenu n'a pas été conçu ni préparé conformément aux exigences légales visant à promouvoir l'indépendance de la recherche en investissement et, en tant que tel, il serait considéré comme une communication marketing selon les lois et réglementations applicables. Veuillez vous assurer que vous avez lu et compris notre Avis sur la recherche en investissement non indépendante et notre avertissement sur les risques concernant les informations susdites, qui peuvent consultés ici.
