Competitive dynamics in focus as US tries to stop Tapestry-Capri merger
Adds details from opening statement and witness testimony in paragraphs 4-11
By Siddharth Cavale
NEW YORK, Sept 9 (Reuters) -The U.S. Federal Trade Commission urgeda federal judge in New York to block Tapestry's TPR.N $8.5 billion merger with rival handbag maker Capri Holdings CPRI.N at a trial on Monday, arguing it will eliminate fierce competition in the market for "accessible luxury."
The FTC argues the merger announced in August 2023 would eliminate head-to-head competition between Tapestry's Coach and Kate Spade brands and Capri's Michael Kors' brands, which has resulted in better prices, discounts and promotions for consumers and wages and workplace benefits for employees.
The deal would also give Tapestry a dominant share of the "accessible luxury" handbag market, controlling over 50% of it once the deal is completed. The regulator defined the "accessible luxury" market as handbags sold between $100 and below $1,000, which forms most of Coach and Kors' lines.
FTC Chief Trial Counsel Nicole Lindquist told U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon in a packed courtroom that the brunt of a merger would be borne by "the working and middle class women of America."
In its questioning of Capri CEO John Idol, the FTC showed evidence of emails between Idol and his deputies, including Jaryn Bloom, president of North America retail for Capri's Michael Kors brand, asking how Coach's outlets were keeping prices down.
"Look at these prices!" Idol wrote in the emails, urging his deputies to come up with better designs and solutions to compete against Coach. In another email produced by the FTC, Idol asks to talk to a deputy about the design of a Coach handbag.
"They monitor and react to each other's every move," said Lindquist, the FTC lawyer.
Tapestry, in response, argues that the U.S. handbag market is highly fragmented and competitive with low barriers to entry and fickle consumer tastes. It also said FTC's analysis misunderstands the handbag marketplace and the way consumers shop and that "accessible luxury" is a notional concept.
Tapestry lawyer Lawrence Buterman said the FTC's argument is divorced from the commercial reality of the handbag market where customers are inundated with choice.
"The commercial reality is that customers have a Gucci bag lined up next to a Kors bag, lined up next to a Calvin Klein bag," he said.
A lawyer for Capri later told the court that Kors had been losing relevance with shoppers since it peaked in 2016 and that growing competition drove the average price for a Kors handbag to $92, below the FTC's threshold of accessible luxury.
The FTC has sued to block several mergers over the past year, making for a busy schedule.
The antitrust regulator is currently fighting to block supermarket chain Kroger's KR.N acquisition of Albertsons ACI.N in a federal court in Portland, Oregon and has also sued to block the $4 billion acquisition of Mattress Firm by mattress manufacturer Tempur Sealy International TPX.N.
Monday's trial is expected to last for a week and a half.
The trial follows the merger's approval by antitrust regulators in Japan and the European Union earlier this year.
Reporting by Siddharth Cavale in New York; editing by Diane Craft and Chizu Nomiyama
Activos relacionados
Últimas noticias
Descargo de responsabilidades: Cada una de las entidades de XM Group proporciona un servicio de solo ejecución y acceso a nuestra plataforma de trading online, permitiendo a una persona ver o usar el contenido disponible en o a través del sitio web, sin intención de cambiarlo ni ampliarlo. Dicho acceso y uso están sujetos en todo momento a: (i) Términos y Condiciones; (ii) Advertencias de riesgo; y (iii) Descargo completo de responsabilidades. Por lo tanto, dicho contenido se proporciona exclusivamente como información general. En particular, por favor tenga en cuenta que, los contenidos de nuestra plataforma de trading online no son ni solicitud ni una oferta para entrar a realizar transacciones en los mercados financieros. Operar en cualquier mercado financiero implica un nivel de riesgo significativo para su capital.
Todo el material publicado en nuestra plataforma de trading online tiene únicamente fines educativos/informativos y no contiene –y no debe considerarse que contenga– asesoramiento ni recomendaciones financieras, tributarias o de inversión, ni un registro de nuestros precios de trading, ni una oferta ni solicitud de transacción con instrumentos financieros ni promociones financieras no solicitadas.
Cualquier contenido de terceros, así como el contenido preparado por XM, como por ejemplo opiniones, noticias, investigaciones, análisis, precios, otras informaciones o enlaces a sitios de terceros que figuran en este sitio web se proporcionan “tal cual”, como comentarios generales del mercado y no constituyen un asesoramiento en materia de inversión. En la medida en que cualquier contenido se interprete como investigación de inversión, usted debe tener en cuenta y aceptar que dicho contenido no fue concebido ni elaborado de acuerdo con los requisitos legales diseñados para promover la independencia en materia de investigación de inversiones y, por tanto, se considera como una comunicación comercial en virtud de las leyes y regulaciones pertinentes. Por favor, asegúrese de haber leído y comprendido nuestro Aviso sobre investigación de inversión no independiente y advertencia de riesgo en relación con la información anterior, al que se puede acceder aquí.
