Green hydrogen fever gets needed doses of reality
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Antony Currie
MELBOURNE, Aug 1 (Reuters Breakingviews) -Hot air is seeping out of the green hydrogen bubble. Over the past five years fans of the low-carbon gas have argued it can replace fossil fuel in everything from industrial processes to heating homes to transport. Yet cost and science make many of its applications fanciful. Developments in July at two big proponents of the technology suggest the industry may be about to get more practical and smaller.
European Union auditors, for instance, have called the bloc's target of producing 10 million tons of green hydrogen and importing as much again by 2030 as "overly optimistic" and lacking "robust analyses". Fortescue FMG.AX, meanwhile, has just ditched its goal of producing 15 million tons a year by 2030. Andrew Forrest, the $38 billion Australian iron ore miner's founder and a climate campaigner, has been one of the gas' most vocal backers, calling sceptics "muppets".
Forrest blames high energy costs for the pullback from the gas extracted from water using renewable energy. That's just one of many factors though. The scale of power needed is daunting: using green hydrogen in all steelmaking, aviation and shipping would require almost five times the solar and wind capacity installed globally in 2022, says Michael Liebreich, co-managing partner at EcoPragma Capital. The storage and shipping capacity required is also higher than for the conventional hydrogen made from fossil fuels.
All in, producing green hydrogen, for most companies, would currently cost at least $6 a kilogramme, four times the expense of producing the dirtier version of the gas, per Liebreich. He notes, using International Energy Agency data, that just 1% of some 1600 green hydrogen projects by production volume have progressed much beyond the exploratory stage.
And as a fuel it is incredibly wasteful. At least 70% of the energy is lost to making and moving it by the time it lands in, say, a hydrogen-powered car, like the 500 Mirai models Toyota Motor 7203.T supplied to the Paris Olympics; for pure electric vehicles, the loss is just 20%, according to White House climate adviser Saul Griffith.
The concept still has some clear uses. It could replace the natural, or fossil, gas that currently creates around 100 million tons a year of hydrogen for manufacturing fertiliser, petrochemicals and other products. It could replace coal in at least some steelmaking, which is where Forrest is now focusing Fortescue's efforts. And it could play a small role in other applications, say as emergency long-term backup in some electricity grids.
But electric batteries, heatpumps and biogas are usually better alternatives to green hydrogen for power, heating and transport - from cars to jet fuel. Trying to compete with them will just burn money.
Follow @AntonyMCurrie on X
CONTEXT NEWS
Fortescue Energy CEO Mark Hutchinson on July 25 said the company is "steadfast in its commitment to green hydgrogen".
He was speaking to investors and analysts a week after parent company Fortescue said it was putting on hold its target of producing 15 million tons of green hydrogen by 2030.
On July 17 the European Court of Auditors published a report saying that the European Union is unlikely to meet its "overly ambitious" goals of producing 10 million tons of green hydrogen and importing a further 10 million tons by 2030.
Editing by Una Galani and Katrina Hamlin
āĻ¸āĻŽā§āĻĒāĻ°ā§āĻāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻ ā§āĻ¯āĻžāĻ¸ā§āĻ
āĻ¸āĻ°ā§āĻŦāĻļā§āĻˇ āĻāĻŦāĻ°
āĻĻāĻžāĻŦāĻŋāĻ¤ā§āĻ¯āĻžāĻ: XM Group āĻāĻ° āĻ¸āĻ¤ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻŦāĻžāĻā§āĻ˛ā§ āĻļā§āĻ§ā§āĻŽāĻžāĻ¤ā§āĻ° āĻāĻžāĻ°ā§āĻ¯āĻāĻ° āĻ¸ā§āĻŦāĻž āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻĻāĻžāĻ¨ āĻāĻ°ā§ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻāĻŽāĻžāĻĻā§āĻ° āĻ āĻ¨āĻ˛āĻžāĻāĻ¨ āĻā§āĻ°ā§āĻĄāĻŋāĻ āĻ¸ā§āĻŦāĻŋāĻ§āĻž āĻā§āĻ˛ā§ āĻāĻĒāĻā§āĻ āĻāĻ°āĻ¤ā§ āĻĻā§ā§, āĻ¸ā§āĻāĻ¸āĻžāĻĨā§ āĻāĻāĻāĻ¨ āĻŦā§āĻ¯āĻā§āĻ¤āĻŋāĻā§ āĻāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻŦāĻ¸āĻžāĻāĻā§ āĻŦāĻž āĻāĻ° āĻŽāĻžāĻ§ā§āĻ¯āĻŽā§ āĻāĻĒāĻ˛āĻŦā§āĻ§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇāĻ¯āĻŧāĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§ āĻĻā§āĻāĻ¤ā§ āĻāĻŦāĻ/āĻ āĻĨāĻŦāĻž āĻŦā§āĻ¯āĻŦāĻšāĻžāĻ° āĻāĻ°āĻžāĻ° āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻŽāĻ¤āĻŋ āĻĻā§ā§ āĻ¤āĻŦā§ āĻāĻāĻŋ āĻā§āĻ¨ āĻĒāĻ°āĻŋāĻŦāĻ°ā§āĻ¤āĻ¨ āĻŦāĻž āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻ¸āĻžāĻ°āĻŋāĻ¤ āĻāĻ°āĻžāĻ° āĻāĻĻā§āĻĻā§āĻļā§āĻ¯ā§ āĻ¨āĻ¯āĻŧ āĻŦāĻž āĻāĻŽāĻ¨ āĻā§āĻ¨ āĻāĻžāĻ°āĻŖā§āĻ āĻ¨āĻ¯āĻŧāĨ¤ āĻāĻ āĻ§āĻ°āĻ¨ā§āĻ° āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻŦā§āĻļ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻŦā§āĻ¯āĻŦāĻšāĻžāĻ° āĻ¸āĻŦāĻ¸āĻŽāĻ¯āĻŧ āĻāĻŋāĻā§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇā§ā§āĻ° āĻ¸āĻžāĻĨā§ āĻā§āĻŋāĻ¤: (i) āĻļāĻ°ā§āĻ¤āĻžāĻŦāĻ˛ā§; (ii) āĻā§āĻāĻāĻŋ āĻ¸āĻ¤āĻ°ā§āĻāĻ¤āĻž; āĻāĻŦāĻ (iii) āĻ¸āĻŽā§āĻĒā§āĻ°ā§āĻŖ āĻĻāĻžāĻŦāĻŋāĻ¤ā§āĻ¯āĻžāĻāĨ¤ āĻāĻ āĻ§āĻ°āĻ¨ā§āĻ° āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇāĻ¯āĻŧāĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§ āĻ¤āĻžāĻ āĻ¸āĻžāĻ§āĻžāĻ°āĻŖ āĻ¤āĻĨā§āĻ¯ āĻšāĻŋāĻ¸ā§āĻŦā§ āĻāĻžāĻĄāĻŧāĻž āĻāĻ° āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻ¯ āĻā§āĻ¨ āĻāĻĻā§āĻĻā§āĻļā§āĻ¯ā§ āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻĻāĻžāĻ¨ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻšāĻ¯āĻŧ āĻ¨āĻžāĨ¤ āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻā§āĻ°āĻš āĻāĻ°ā§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻļā§āĻˇāĻāĻžāĻŦā§ āĻ¸āĻā§āĻ¤āĻ¨ āĻĨāĻžāĻā§āĻ¨ āĻ¯ā§, āĻāĻŽāĻžāĻĻā§āĻ° āĻ āĻ¨āĻ˛āĻžāĻāĻ¨ āĻā§āĻ°ā§āĻĄāĻŋāĻ āĻ¸ā§āĻŦāĻŋāĻ§āĻžāĻ° āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇāĻ¯āĻŧāĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻā§ā§āĻ˛ā§ āĻāĻ°ā§āĻĨāĻŋāĻ āĻŦāĻžāĻāĻžāĻ°ā§ āĻā§āĻ¨ā§ āĻ˛ā§āĻ¨āĻĻā§āĻ¨ āĻāĻ°āĻžāĻ° āĻāĻ¨ā§āĻ¯ āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻ°ā§āĻ§ āĻŦāĻž āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻ¸ā§āĻ¤āĻžāĻŦ āĻ¨āĻ¯āĻŧāĨ¤ āĻāĻžāĻ°āĻŖ āĻ¯ā§āĻā§āĻ¨ā§ āĻāĻ°ā§āĻĨāĻŋāĻ āĻŦāĻžāĻāĻžāĻ°ā§ āĻā§āĻ°ā§āĻĄāĻŋāĻ āĻāĻ°āĻ˛ā§ āĻāĻĒāĻ¨āĻžāĻ° āĻŽā§āĻ˛āĻ§āĻ¨ā§āĻ° āĻ¸āĻžāĻĨā§ āĻāĻāĻāĻŋ āĻāĻ˛ā§āĻ˛ā§āĻāĻ¯ā§āĻā§āĻ¯ āĻā§āĻāĻāĻŋ āĻāĻĄāĻŧāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻĨāĻžāĻāĻŦā§āĨ¤
āĻāĻŽāĻžāĻĻā§āĻ° āĻ āĻ¨āĻ˛āĻžāĻāĻ¨ āĻā§āĻ°ā§āĻĄāĻŋāĻ āĻ¸ā§āĻŦāĻŋāĻ§āĻžāĻ¯āĻŧ āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻāĻžāĻļāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻ¸āĻāĻ˛ āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇā§āĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§ āĻļā§āĻ§ā§āĻŽāĻžāĻ¤ā§āĻ° āĻļāĻŋāĻā§āĻˇāĻžāĻāĻ¤/āĻ¤āĻĨā§āĻ¯āĻŽā§āĻ˛āĻ āĻāĻĻā§āĻĻā§āĻļā§āĻ¯ā§ āĻ¤ā§āĻ°āĻŋ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻšāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻāĻ¤ā§ āĻāĻ°ā§āĻĨāĻŋāĻ, āĻŦāĻŋāĻ¨āĻŋāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻ āĻāĻ° āĻŦāĻž āĻā§āĻ°ā§āĻĄāĻŋāĻ āĻĒāĻ°āĻžāĻŽāĻ°ā§āĻļ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻ¸ā§āĻĒāĻžāĻ°āĻŋāĻļ āĻ§āĻžāĻ°āĻŖ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻāĻāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻ¨āĻ¯āĻŧ - āĻāĻŽāĻžāĻĻā§āĻ° āĻā§āĻ°ā§āĻĄāĻŋāĻ āĻŽā§āĻ˛ā§āĻ¯ā§āĻ° āĻāĻāĻāĻŋ āĻ°ā§āĻāĻ°ā§āĻĄ; āĻ āĻĨāĻŦāĻž āĻā§āĻ¨ā§ āĻāĻ°ā§āĻĨāĻŋāĻ āĻāĻĒāĻāĻ°āĻŖā§ āĻ˛ā§āĻ¨āĻĻā§āĻ¨ā§āĻ° āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻ¸ā§āĻ¤āĻžāĻŦ, āĻŦāĻž āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻ°ā§āĻ§; āĻ āĻĨāĻŦāĻž āĻāĻĒāĻ¨āĻžāĻ° āĻāĻžāĻā§ āĻ āĻ¯āĻžāĻāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻāĻ°ā§āĻĨāĻŋāĻ āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻāĻžāĻ° āĻšāĻŋāĻ¸ā§āĻŦā§ āĻāĻāĻŋāĻā§ āĻ§āĻžāĻ°āĻŖ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻāĻāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻ¨āĻ¯āĻŧāĨ¤
āĻā§āĻ¨ āĻ¤ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻ¯āĻŧ āĻĒāĻā§āĻˇā§āĻ° āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇā§āĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§, āĻĒāĻžāĻļāĻžāĻĒāĻžāĻļāĻŋ XM āĻĻā§āĻŦāĻžāĻ°āĻž āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻ¤ āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇā§ āĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§ āĻ¯ā§āĻŽāĻ¨ āĻŽāĻ¤āĻžāĻŽāĻ¤, āĻ¸āĻāĻŦāĻžāĻĻ, āĻāĻŦā§āĻˇāĻŖāĻž, āĻŦāĻŋāĻļā§āĻ˛ā§āĻˇāĻŖ, āĻĻāĻžāĻŽ, āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻ¯āĻžāĻ¨ā§āĻ¯ āĻ¤āĻĨā§āĻ¯ āĻŦāĻž āĻāĻ āĻāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻŦāĻ¸āĻžāĻāĻā§ āĻĨāĻžāĻāĻž āĻ¤ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻ¯āĻŧ āĻĒāĻā§āĻˇā§āĻ° āĻ¸āĻžāĻāĻā§āĻ° āĻ˛āĻŋāĻāĻ āĻā§āĻ˛ā§ "āĻ¯ā§āĻŽāĻ¨-āĻ°āĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻā§" āĻāĻŋāĻ¤ā§āĻ¤āĻŋāĻ¤ā§ āĻ¸āĻ°āĻŦāĻ°āĻžāĻš āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻšāĻ¯āĻŧ āĻ¸āĻžāĻ§āĻžāĻ°āĻŖ āĻŽāĻžāĻ°ā§āĻā§āĻā§āĻ° āĻāĻžāĻˇā§āĻ¯ āĻšāĻŋāĻ¸ā§āĻŦā§ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻŦāĻŋāĻ¨āĻŋāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻā§āĻ° āĻĒāĻ°āĻžāĻŽāĻ°ā§āĻļ āĻāĻ āĻ¨ āĻāĻ°āĻŦā§āĻ¨ āĻ¨āĻžāĨ¤ āĻ¯ā§āĻā§āĻ¨ā§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇāĻ¯āĻŧāĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻā§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻ¨āĻŋāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻ āĻāĻŦā§āĻˇāĻŖāĻž āĻšāĻŋāĻ¸ā§āĻŦā§ āĻŦā§āĻāĻžāĻ¨ā§ āĻšāĻ˛ā§, āĻāĻĒāĻ¨āĻžāĻā§ āĻ āĻŦāĻļā§āĻ¯āĻ āĻŽāĻ¨ā§ āĻ°āĻžāĻāĻ¤ā§ āĻšāĻŦā§ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻ¸ā§āĻŦā§āĻāĻžāĻ° āĻāĻ°āĻ¤ā§ āĻšāĻŦā§ āĻ¯ā§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻˇāĻ¯āĻŧāĻŦāĻ¸ā§āĻ¤ā§āĻāĻŋ āĻŦāĻŋāĻ¨āĻŋāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻ āĻāĻŦā§āĻˇāĻŖāĻžāĻ° āĻ¸ā§āĻŦāĻžāĻ§ā§āĻ¨āĻ¤āĻžāĻ° āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻāĻžāĻ°ā§āĻ° āĻāĻ¨ā§āĻ¯ āĻĄāĻŋāĻāĻžāĻāĻ¨ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻāĻāĻ¨āĻŋ āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻāĻ¨ā§āĻ¯āĻŧāĻ¤āĻž āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻ¸āĻžāĻ°ā§ āĻ¤ā§āĻ°āĻŋ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻšāĻ¯āĻŧāĻ¨āĻŋ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻāĻāĻŋ āĻŦāĻŋāĻŦā§āĻāĻ¨āĻž āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻšāĻŦā§ āĻ¨āĻž āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻžāĻ¸āĻā§āĻāĻŋāĻ āĻāĻāĻ¨ āĻ āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻŦāĻŋāĻ§āĻžāĻ¨ā§āĻ° āĻ āĻ§ā§āĻ¨ā§ āĻŦāĻŋāĻĒāĻŖāĻ¨ āĻ¯ā§āĻāĻžāĻ¯ā§āĻ āĻšāĻŋāĻ¸ā§āĻŦā§āĨ¤ āĻ āĻ¨ā§āĻā§āĻ°āĻš āĻāĻ°ā§ āĻ¨āĻŋāĻļā§āĻāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻāĻ°ā§āĻ¨ āĻ¯ā§ āĻāĻĒāĻ¨āĻŋ āĻ -āĻ¸ā§āĻŦāĻžāĻ§ā§āĻ¨ āĻŦāĻŋāĻ¨āĻŋāĻ¯āĻŧā§āĻ āĻ¸āĻāĻā§āĻ°āĻžāĻ¨ā§āĻ¤ āĻāĻŽāĻžāĻĻā§āĻ° āĻŦāĻŋāĻā§āĻāĻĒā§āĻ¤āĻŋ āĻĒāĻĄāĻŧā§āĻā§āĻ¨ āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻŦā§āĻā§āĻā§āĻ¨āĨ¤ āĻĒā§āĻ°ā§āĻŦā§āĻā§āĻ¤ āĻ¤āĻĨā§āĻ¯ āĻ¸āĻŽā§āĻĒāĻ°ā§āĻāĻŋāĻ¤ āĻāĻŦā§āĻˇāĻŖāĻž āĻāĻŦāĻ āĻā§āĻāĻāĻŋ āĻ¸āĻ¤āĻ°ā§āĻāĻ¤āĻž, āĻ¯āĻž āĻāĻāĻžāĻ¨ āĻĨā§āĻā§ āĻĒā§āĻ°āĻŦā§āĻļ āĻāĻ°āĻž āĻ¯ā§āĻ¤ā§ āĻĒāĻžāĻ°ā§āĨ¤